When you’re getting serious about barbecue, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is what style of smoker to invest in. Two very popular options in the world of traditional barbecue are classic offset smokers and Ole Hickory CTOs (Cabinet Type Offsets). Both use charcoal and wood to generate heat and smoke, but they behave quite differently and appeal to different types of pitmasters.
In this post, we’ll explore how they compare, what each does best, and how to choose the right one for your BBQ goals.
⸻
What Is an Offset Smoker?
Classic offset smokers are the quintessential “backyard BBQ” smoker. They consist of:
• A horizontal cooking chamber where your food sits.
• A firebox offset to one side where the fuel burns.
• Heat and smoke flowing from the firebox into the main chamber.
They’re beloved for producing deep smoke flavor and the “true barbecue experience,” but they do take skill to master.
⸻
What Is an Ole Hickory CTO?
The Ole Hickory CTO is a type of offset smoker that builds on the classic design with a cabinet-style cooking chamber:
• The cabinet is tall and roomy, with multiple racks.
• Heat and smoke circulate more evenly due to internal baffling and the cabinet shape.
• Often seen as a “more refined” offset design, balancing tradition with smoother performance.
Think of a CTO as a premium, purpose-built offset smoker that tries to solve many of the challenges of simpler offsets.
⸻
Head-to-Head Comparison
Here’s how traditional offset smokers and Ole Hickory CTOs stack up across key barbecue qualities:
Heat Consistency & Control
Classic Offsets:
• Can develop hot and cool spots.
• Require frequent adjustment of dampers and fire management.
• Challenge is part of the craft — but it takes experience.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Cabinet design promotes more even airflow and heat distribution.
• Easier to maintain stable temps across multiple racks.
• Less fiddling = more consistent results for long cooks.
Winner: CTO (for consistency), Offset (for hands-on control)
⸻
Smoke Flavor
Classic Offsets:
• Direct path from firebox into cooking chamber gives strong, rich smoke flavor.
• Flavor intensity is variable — part of artisan appeal.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Still robust smoke flavor, but slightly tempered by airflow and volume.
• Offers a balanced, wood-smoke profile that’s easier to dial in.
Winner: Offset (for maximum intensity), CTO close behind
⸻
Cooking Capacity
Classic Offsets:
• Varies widely by model; many are wide but have limited vertical space.
• Stacking racks can be tricky.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Tall cabinet with lots of racks = big capacity.
• Great for feeding crowds or competition loads.
Winner: CTO
⸻
Ease of Use
Classic Offsets:
• Steep learning curve.
• Fire management + damper control require attention.
• Reward comes with experience.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Better airflow design makes low-and-slow more predictable.
• Great choice for cooks who want offset flavor with less guesswork.
Winner: CTO
⸻
Build Quality & Durability
This one depends on brand and model, but:
Classic Offsets:
• Many backyard models are thinner steel and less insulated.
• Can be more susceptible to temperature swings from wind or cold.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Heavier steel and more substantial build.
• Cabinet design tends to retain heat better.
Winner: CTO (generally)
⸻
Price
Classic Offsets:
• Wide range, from budget builds to premium competition rigs.
• Lower-cost options exist.
Ole Hickory CTOs:
• Mid-to-high price range.
• Built for serious BBQers willing to invest.
Winner: Offset (for budget flexibility)
⸻
So Which Should You Choose?
Here are some decision shortcuts based on your goals:
You want the purest, most traditional smoke experience
Classic Offset Smoker
If you love tending a fire, manipulating airflow, and chasing perfect smoke flavor — the challenge is part of the fun.
You want offset flavor with more predictability
Ole Hickory CTO
If your priority is consistent temperature, big capacity, and a smoother learning curve without sacrificing real smoke taste, a CTO is hard to beat.
You’re feeding a crowd
Ole Hickory CTO
The cabinet design and rack space make it excellent for briskets, whole hogs, ribs, and large competition loads.
You’re on a tight budget
Classic Offset
There are great backyard offsets at lower price points; just be ready to invest time learning the craft.
⸻
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, both classic offset smokers and Ole Hickory CTOs produce amazing barbecue.